Each and all of the following facts are clearly confirmed by a perponderance of DOCUMENTED LEGAL EVIDENCE:

1)  OCTOBER, 1998:  Ex-wife anticipates inheriting $250,000 and decides to divorce MOST DEVOTED FATHER (Joshua Ryan Sinclair).

 2)  1/25/99:  Ex-wife falsely accuses MOST DEVOTED FATHER (A "Stay-At-Home Dad" and the children's "PRIMARY CAREGIVER") of being abusive in desperate attempts to seize advantage in bitter custody dispute, and is instantly granted "Order Of Protection" compelling MOST DEVOTED FATHER to immediately "VACATE" and "STAY-AWAY" from home and children, Evan & Ethan Sinclair - Enabling ex-wife to seize "SOLE-CUSTODY" of children and possession of MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S vital business supplies and equipment.  Ex-wife's new boyfriend (and co-worker), Tim, promptly begins moving into MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S home with then-wife and Evan & Ethan.

 3)  2/25/99:  Ex-wife and new [live-in] boyfriend file FRAUDULENT "JOINT" NYS & FED. INCOME TAX RETURNS for 1998 - Using and evidently forging MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S NAME - And also drafts a false (inaccurate) and fraudulent "Profit or Loss Statement" for MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S homebased business and files it with their fraudulent "Joint" Income Tax Returns.

4)  5/31/99:  MOST DEVOTED FATHER, living in 1988 Dodge Conversion Van in parking lot at Ontario Beach Park still opens and attempts to operate [seasonal] "Designer Boutique And Souvenir Shop" in Ontario Beach Park Bathhouse, but ex-wife repeatedly refuses to release vital business supplies and equipment (which MOST DEVOTED FATHER had to leave behind when unjustly forced to leave marital residence on 1/25/99), including sewing machine, fabrics, finished fashions, beach toys and towels, tanning supplies, sunglasses, and souvenirs etc. - Making it virtually impossible for MOST DEVOTED FATHER to successfully operate business and generate an income.

5)  SUMMER, 1999:  Ex-wife (who had 1996 Ford Explorer - which was purchased at Dick Ide dealership in Penfield, NY, and paid for in cash and in full with funds taken from Living Trust of ex-wife's elderly Aunt, Florence Tesmer - and had live-in boyfriend who also had a late-model SUV) began hiring towing companies and sending them to Ontario Beach Park in attempts to seize 1988 Dodge Conversion Van which MOST DEVOTED FATHER was forced to live & sleep in.

 6)  7/18/99:  Ex-wife manipulates Society for the Protection and Care of Children (S.P.C.C.) to "TERMINATE" MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S Family Court-Stipulated "Supervised Visits" because MOST DEVOTED FATHER (who does not celebrate birthdays and holidays because of religious beliefs) would NOT agree to stop bringing and giving "GIFTS" such as "TOYS, BOOKS, CLOTHING, CANDY, ETC." to the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S children, Evan & Ethan, except "on birthdays and holidays only."  PARENTAL ALIENATON BEGINS 

7a)  10/5/99:  Ex-wife granted fraudulent "DEFAULT" Divorce Judgment giving ex-wife "SOLE-CUSTODY" of children, Evan & Ethan Sinclair, and "100%  of Marriage Property" (In other words, the "Marital Residence" and everything in it - Including virtually all of the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S personal belongings) - without any divorce or custody hearings ever being conducted - by falsely claiming to court that MOST DEVOTED FATHER abandoned family and that they did not know the whereabouts of the MOST DEVOTED FATHER, and that the MOST DEVOTED FATHER never responded to their divorce papers - Which the MOST DEVOTED FATHER did, in fact, do via "Certified Mail."

7b)  Also included among the "100% of the Marriage Property" ex-wife was allowed to unlawfully seize via fraudulent "Default" Divorce Judgment was Finished "Unique and ONE-OF-A-KIND, hand-made fashions" designed and manufactured by the MOST DEVOTED FATHER; The Canopy and complete set-up previously used by the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to display and sell fashions at Arts & Craft Festivals; Finished artwork previously produced by the MOST DEVOTED FATEHER as a freelance commercial artist); Photographic equipment, Photos and Negatives from virtually all of the photo assignments that the MOST DEVOTED FATHER was previously commissioned to perform as a freelance photographer (weddings etc.); And a coin collection passed-down to the MOST DEVOTED FATHER from his mother, etc. etc. etc. - All with an accumulated total value of ten's of thousands of dollars.

 8a)  LATE OCTOBER, 1999:  MOST DEVOTED FATHER is "Served" with an undeniably "DOCTORED" copy of ex-wife's fraudulent "Default" Divorce Judgment - Which ex-wife's attorney deliberately altered in a blatant act of attempted extortion and in attempts to trick the MOST DEVOTED FATHER into paying $379.39 EACH WEEK for "Child Support" - Although the "True Copy" of the "Default" Divorce Judgment which was subsequently obtained by the MOST DEVOTED FATHER revealed that Judge Charles T. Maloy actually calculated and ordered the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to pay $188.23 EACH WEEK.  Ex-wife's attorney later claimed it was "an honest mistake".

8b)  Ex-wife and her attorney also requested (in writing) that Judge Maloy order the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to acquire and pay for Health Insurance for Evan & Ethan - even though their mother is a NYS Civil Service Employee and already has full Health Insurance benefits for herself and for Evan & Ethan - And to order the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to obtain a Life Insurance policy on the MOST DEVOTED FATHER and to name ex-wife as the "Beneficiary"!!!  Judge Maloy denied both of those requests.

 9)  OCTOBER, 1999:  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER files a Family Court petition for "Custody/Visitation", and a "Violation Petition" because of ex-wife's blatant violation of the "Stipulations" in her [fraudulent] "Order Of Protection" regarding the rights of the MOST DEVOTED FATHER ~ AND SONS to have "Visitation" (albeit "Supervised" because ex-wife claimed that she was afraid the MOST DEVOTED FATHER might attempt to "flee" with Evan & Ethan - Which is exactly what SHE admittedly attempted to do on 1/24/99 with Evan & Ethan and on 1/25/99 with just Evan); And contact "Via Telephone"; And contact "Via Mail".  However, both of the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S petitions were simply "DISMISSED" within minutes, after Family Court Judge/Judicial Hearing Officer listened to response from ex-wife's attorney and would not allow MOST DEVOTED FATHER to speak.

10)  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER files Family Court petition for "Modification of Child Support" stressing the fact that the "Default" Divorce Judgment was, in fact, fraudulently obtained since Judge Maloy was evidently deceived into believing the MOST DEVOTED FATHER abandoned family and did not respond to ex-wife's divorce papers, and that ex-wife was unaware of the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S whereabouts etc.   However, the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S petition for "Child Support Modification" was also simply "DISMISSED" by Judicial Hearing Examiner Ruben Garcia, despite all of the aforementioned facts.

11a)  11/5/99:  Ex-wife calls 911 apparently claiming the 1988 Dodge Conversion Van (which the MOST DEVOTED FATHER was still living in) was stolen.  However,  after the Police evidently met with ex-wife to take report and noticed ex-wife and her live-in boyfriend both had late-model SUV's, and later approached the van and discovered that MOST DEVOTED FATHER was, in fact, ex-husband and was forced to live in the van because of a very bitter divorce situation, the Police refused to seize the van for 'greedy and/or malicious' ex-wife.  However, ex-wife insisted that Police remove the van's license plates and return them to her, which they agreed to do.

11b)  Subsequently, ex-wife (and live-in boyfriend) evidently sent someone to put sugar and/or molasses in the fuel tank of the 1988 Dodge Conversion Van that the MOST DEVOTED FATHER was living in - destroying the van's motor - and also eventually succeeded in having inoperable van towed to salvage yard to salvage yard near ex-wife's attorney's office in Penfield, NY.  Shortly thereafter, the MOST DEVOTED FATHER was invited to move in with and be live-in caregiver for elderly widow who was also attempting to care for two of her disabled relatives.  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER (an ordained minister - who admittedly became "distracted" and previously "drifted-away") accepted invitation, perceiving it to be guidance from THE ONLY TRUE GOD to concentrate on assisting and advocating for OTHERS who are living with advercities (Phil. 2:3-5 & James 1:27).

12)  11/7/99:  LAST TIME THE MOST DEVOTED FATHER, JOSHUA RYAN SINCLAIR, IS ALLOWED TO SEE SONS, EVAN & ETHAN SINCLAIR - "For five (5) minutes only!" (ex-wife's words) 

 13)  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER files complaint about J.H.E. Garcia and reiterated to the Court the fact that the MOST DEVOTED FATHER was unemployed and without an income and that ex-wife previously seized - and refused to release - the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S vital business supplies and equipment, making it virtually impossible for the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to successfully operate business and generate an income.  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER also obtained "True Copy" of the fraudulent "Default" Divorce Judgment (confirming "Child Support" figures in the copy that was previously "Served" upon the MOST DEVOTED FATHER by ex-wife's attorney was, in fact, "DOCTORED").  And the MOST DEVOTED FATHER also noticed the fact that ex-wife and her attorney also deliberately refrained from including in their "Financial Disclosure Affidavit" the fact that ex-wife had by then inherited nearly $250,000 - Plus the fact that ex-wife had a live-in boyfriend (and his income).  Hence, the Honorable Joan Kohout calls J.H.E. Garcia's actions 'AN ABUSE OF DISCRETION' and ordered J.H.E. Garcia to re-open the case.  However, J.H.E. Garcia again refuses to consider (or even listen to) any of the aforementioned facts and documented evidence of fraud (including ex-wife's false "Financial Disclosure Affidavit") and J.H.E. Garcia simply instructs ex-wife's attorney to "IMPUTE" an income for the MOST DEVOTED FATHER, which he promptly accepted and then ordered the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to pay an amount of Child Support based on the amount of income the ex-wife's attorney imputed for the MOST DEVOTED FATHER. 

 14)  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER files another complaint against J.H.E. Garcia.  However, second complaint is "DENIED" by [Wanna-be-Activist] Family Court Judge, Marilyn O'Connor (without holding any hearings) who issued an additional Family Court Order compelling the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to 'give up homebased business and get a regular job.' (instead of ordering ex-wife to return the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S vital business supplies and equipment) - Because ex-wife and her attorney claimed that the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S business was not capable of generating enough income to provide ex-wife with the amount of "Child Support" she claimed to need (albeit CRAVED). 

15)  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER files petition with the NYS Supreme Court, asking Court to "Vacate" ex-wife's fraudulent "Default" Divorce Judgment - ESPECIALLY SO THAT EXTREMELY IMPORTANT ISSUE OF "CUSTODY" OF EVAN & ETHAN SINCLAIR SHOULD BE DETERMINED BASED ON THE "MERITS" (including all of the "FACTS" and "EVIDENCE" and the testimony of BOTH SIDES) - And also especially because of the fact that Judge Maloy was evidently deceived into believing the MOST DEVOTED FATHER abandoned family and did not respond to ex-wife's divorce papers, and that ex-wife was unaware of the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S whereabouts - Plus, the fact that the "Child Support" figures were clearly "DOCTORED" by ex-wife's attorney - As well as the fact that ex-wife falsely accused the MOST DEVOTED FATHER of being abusive in attempts to seize an advantage in custody dispute.  The Most Devoted Father also reminded the Court that NYS Law supposedly requires "EQUITABLE DISTRIBUTION" of "Marital Assets", which was denied for the MOST DEVOTED FATHER because of ex-wife's fraudulent "Default" Divorce Judgment - despite the guarantee in the U.S. Constitution that 'NO ONE shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property without DUE PROCESS of law' - Nevertheless, NYS Supreme Court Justice Robert Lunn "DENIED" the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S petition, within minutes, after simply asking ex-wife's attorney for their response to the petition and refusing to allow the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to speak.

16)  DATE UNKNOWN (???):  Ex-wife uses fraudulent "Default" Divorce Judgment (which gave her "100% of Marriage Property") to remove the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S name from the title on the Marital Residence and promptly sold Marital Residence in Rochester, NY, and moved with the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S sons, Evan C. Sinclair and Ethan F. Sinclair (and her live-in boyfriend) into a new home in surburban Penfield, NY (purchased with money from the Living Trust of her elderly Aunt, Florence Tesmer, which she subsequently inherited) - AND REFUSED TO INFORM THE MOST DEVOTED FATHER WHERE THE CHILDREN WERE RELOCATED TO.           

17)  4/24/2000:  LAST TIME THE MOST DEVOTED FATHER WAS ALLOWED TO SPEAK TO CHILDREN VIA TELEPHONE - Even though [weekly] "Telephone Contact" between the MOST DEVOTED FATHER AND SONS was clearly "stipulated" in ex-wife's Order Of Protection - TOTAL PARENTAL ALIENATION BEGINS! 

18a)  7/6/2000:  C.P.S. Investigation Report prepared by Mattie Stevens and Ellen Sciolino concludes under heading "OBSERVATIONS" regarding Evan & Ethan Sinclair (The bi-racial sons of the MOST DEVOTED FATHER, who is African-American and was a "Stay-At-Home Dad" and their "Primary Caregiver"):  "THERE IS CONCERN FOR THE CHILDREN'S EMOTIONAL STABILITY IN REGARDS TO THEM NOT SEEING THEIR FATHER." - However, what is very clearly and indisputably "in the best-interests of the children" - and the MOST DEVOTED FATHER FATHER'S repeated complaints - are COMPLETELY IGNORED AND NO ACTION IS TAKEN BY ANYONE TO BRING THE BLATANT AND MALICIOUS TOTAL PARENTAL ALIENATION AND "ETHNIC CLEANSING" (AND ITS OBVIOUS AND 'OBSERVABLE' DETRIMENTAL EFFECTS ON EVAN & ETHAN) TO AN END! 

18b) DESPITE THE "OBSERVATIONS" AND "CONCLUSION" IN THE ABOVE-MENTIONED CPS INVESTIGATION REPORT (which Monroe County Family Court Judges and Judicial Hearing Officers have repeatedly refused to allow the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to enter as "EVIDENCE") - THE LAST TIME THE MOST DEVOTED FATHER WAS ALLOWED TO SEE EVAN & ETHAN WAS ("FOR FIVE [5] MINUTES ONLY" - EX-WIFE'S WORDS) ON 11/7/99 - AND THE LAST TIME THE MOST DEVOTED FATHER WAS ALLOWED TO SPEAK TO EVAN & ETHAN VIA TELEPHONE WAS ON 4/24/2000 - FURTHER, SINCE 1/25/99, EVAN & ETHAN SINCLAIR HAVE NOT BEEN ALLOWED WRITE TO THEIR MOST DEVOTED [AFRICAN-AMERICAN] FATHER, JOSHUA RYAN SINCLAIR - AND THEIR MOTHER ALSO ADMITTED DURING FAMILY COURT PRECEEDINGS THAT SHE "CONFISCATES" (AND REFUSES TO GIVE TO EVAN & ETHAN) ANY MAIL FROM THEIR FATHER. 

19)  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER has sent several letters including formal complaints to the NYS Department of Taxation and to the Internal Revenue Service regarding the aformentioned FRAUDULENT "JOINT" INCOME TAX RETURNS AND "PROFIT OR LOSS STATEMENT" for 1998, which was filed on 2/25/99 by ex-wife and her live-in boyfriend (evidently with the MOST DEVOTED FATHER'S forged signature) - As of the date of this blog the MOST DEVOTED FATHER still has not received any response or reply regarding the FRAUDULENT Income Tax Returns  and Profit or Loss Statement etc. - However, the MOST DEVOTED FATHER has received notices from the NYS Dept. of Taxation and the I.R.S. informing the MOST DEVOTED FATHER that a "Tax Warrant" has been issued against the MOST DEVOTED FATHER for "Unpaid Child Support."

20)  Since the MOST DEVOTED FATHER had been unable to obtain alternate employment after previously being placed on "DISABILITY LEAVE" and last position was "TERMINATED" (while the MOST DEVOTED FATHER was on "Disability Leave" - which was the reason for starting homebased business) - And since the Family Court refused to order ex-wife to return vital business supplies and equipment, but rather ordered the MOST DEVOTED FATHER to 'give up business' and just 'do it on the side as a hobby' - the MOST DEVOTED FATHER has turned own adversity into tremendous blessing for others by becoming extraordinarily devoted full-time VOLUNTEER (UNPAID) CAREGIVER AND ADVOCATE FOR THE ELDERLY AND DISABLED (often serving as an unpaid "live-in caregiver") And as an incomperably compassionate, tender, and loving [VOLUNTEER] "HOSPICE CARE PROVIDER."  

20b)  The MOST DEVOTED FATHER is now being slandered (almost certainly by annonymous, COWARDLY, members of the Monroe County Chapter of the "Bigots Brigade" in attempts to deflect attention from their undeniable gross injustices and clearly unethical, unlawful, and fraudulent activities and practices as outlined above) - And is thus being labeled and accused of owing approx. $40,000 in back child support and being 'The worse "Dead-Beat" Dad in the State of New York'.

20c)  The slanderers refuse express any concerns whatsoever about - or to even mention - the unjust TOTAL PARENTAL ALIENATION and the blatant and malicious use of Evan & Ethan Sinclair as "PAWNS" and "WEAPONS" against their father (The MOST DEVOTED FATHER, Joshua Ryan Sinclair), and the observations and serious concerns expressed about Evan & Ethan Sinclair in the 7/6/2000 CPS Investigation Report:  "THERE IS CONCERN FOR THE CHILDREN'S EMOTIONAL DEVELOPMENT IN REGARDS TO THEM NOT SEEING THEIR FATHER."

~ WHAT DO YOU THINK? ~